A dealer offers you a low finance rate. Ask the same dealer for a lower price if you bring your own finance, and you may be offered a discount instead. Both offers can look good on their own. The only fair way to choose is to compare what each one costs you in total.
This guide is for buyers with a steady income and a clean credit history who can get a car loan elsewhere and want to compare a dealer's finance offer with a cash price discount. It sets out a worked comparison you can repeat with your own quotes, and the points that change the answer.
Why a low rate is not the whole price
ASIC's Moneysmart guide to car loans says a lender must give you the comparison rate, which combines the interest rate and fees into one figure, and that you should compare the same loan amount and term. That is the right tool for comparing two loans for the same amount.
It does not capture a discount you give up. A comparison rate is worked out on the loan, not on the car's price. If taking the dealer's rate means paying a higher price for the car, that extra price is part of the cost of the finance, but it will not show up in the comparison rate. Our guide to comparison rates versus interest rates covers what the figure includes.
Fees matter too. In its 2026 review of car loans, ASIC found that loans typically had two establishment fees: a lender establishment fee ranging from $299 to $995, and a distributor establishment fee, such as a dealer's or broker's, ranging from a flat $912 up to $2,500. Our guide to car loan fees explains each type.
Worked example: dealer finance or cash discount
These figures are an illustration of the method, not quotes or typical rates. All loans are five years with monthly repayments, and the buyer puts $10,000 of their own money towards the car in both cases.
- Offer A, dealer finance: the car is $50,000 drive away. The buyer borrows $40,000 at 3.99% a year, with a $995 lender fee and a $1,500 dealer fee added to the loan, so $42,495 is financed. Repayments are about $782 a month, and the total repaid is about $46,945.
- Offer B, own finance with a discount: the dealer takes $3,000 off, so the car is $47,000 drive away. The buyer borrows $37,000 from their own lender at 7.99% a year, with a $250 establishment fee added, so $37,250 is financed. Repayments are about $755 a month, and the total repaid is about $45,307.
Adding the $10,000 contribution, Offer A costs about $56,945 in total and Offer B about $55,307. The discount comes out about $1,638 ahead, even though its interest rate is double the dealer's.
The answer depends on the rate you can get elsewhere. With the same discount and fees, Offer B saves about $2,700 at 6.99% and about $561 at 8.99%. It only stops winning once your own loan rate passes about 9.51%. That break-even rate is the number to work out for your own quotes. Our guide to how car loan repayments are calculated shows the formula behind these figures.
What changes the answer
- The size of the discount. A bigger discount raises the break-even rate. A small one, or none, can make the low rate the better deal.
- Fees. Fees added to the loan are charged interest for the whole term. A low-rate offer with high fees can cost more than its rate suggests.
- A balloon payment. Some low-rate offers include a large final payment. Compare total cost including the balloon, not just the monthly repayment. Our guide to balloon payments explains the trade-off.
- Extras added to the loan. Insurance products, service plans or accessories bundled into the finance increase what you borrow. Ask for the price of each one separately.
- Paying the loan off early. If you might sell or upgrade before the term ends, check the early repayment terms on both loans. Our guide to paying out a car loan early covers what to ask.
A checklist before you choose
1. Get two written drive-away prices for the same car: one with the dealer's finance and one without it.
2. Line up quotes for the same term. Ask both lenders for the rate, every fee and the comparison rate on the amount you would actually borrow.
3. Add up the totals. Total repayments plus fees plus any balloon plus your own contribution. The lower total wins, all else being equal.
4. Work out your break-even rate. If your own loan rate is below it, the discount is likely to be cheaper.
5. Arrange your own finance first. A car loan pre-approval gives you a real rate to compare and lets you negotiate on price. Our guide to dealer finance, brokers and banks compares the channels.
6. Do not choose on the monthly repayment alone. A longer term or a balloon can make any offer look cheaper each month while costing more in total.
You can test your own figures in the car loan repayment calculator or compare current car loans.
This guide is general information only and does not take your personal circumstances into account. Rates, fees and offers vary, and a lender will assess your application before making an offer.























